Ad/Break (2026)

Tamara Lynn Chambers

as Dolores

Doug Walker

as Nostalgia Critic

Malcolm Ray

as Contestant #1

B

Brett Bonynge

as Contestant #2

R

Robbie Allen

as Bob

A

Alyssa Jackson

as Barbara

P

Paul Rohan

as Ben

J

Jimmy Melf

as Reilly

H

Harry Locke IV

as Julio

J

Jim Jarosz

as Rolly the Fox/Practitioner

H

Heather Reusz

as Atlantis Somerset

N

Nick La Banca

as Nautical Nineties Narrator

J

Justin Hoffman

as "Spin My Helm" Singer

M

McKane Searle

as "Spin My Helm" Bassist

J

James Banasiak

as "Spin My Helm" Drummer

A

Alexis Banasiak

as Waving Woman 1

M

Mooog

as Waving Woman 2

R

Rob Scallon

as Waving Man

C

Catheryn Kuhar

as Sailor Girl

D

Danny Grenchik

as "Shark Weak" Singer